Humor columnist Morris Workman shares his "odd-servations" and twisted perspectives on small-town living, national news, sports, and societal whims. His wit and gentle satire are designed to make you smile, make you laugh, and mostly, make you think.

Friday, October 07, 2005

Bigotry For Fun And Property Value

NOTE-This article was rejected by the Editor of the Desert Valley Times

I’ve been thinking about joining the board of an HOA recently.
It’s not that I have some overwhelming desire to bully innocent lawn ornaments or join the garden-hose patrol, but I can see the advantage to being one of those carrying the whip.
It’s also one of the last places in America where bigotry can be practiced without some group with lots of A’s, U’s, and other vowels in their name threatening to hold their breath and throw lawsuits like so many rocks.
Before you get the wrong idea, the bigotry has nothing to do with skin color.
It’s not about anyone’s cultural heritage.
It’s not even a prejudice against a particular religion.
If you listen to the charlatans beating the association board drum, it is a bias against one of the lowest life forms in the human genome, a group of beings so lowly and despicable that they shouldn’t even be allowed to breathe, much less inhabit a building within the gun-turreted walls of a particular PUD.
According to the “prophets,” these two-legged vermin are responsible for declining property values, dead grass, toy proliferation, noise complaints, diphtheria, and global warming.
Unfortunately, the movement is gaining traction as innocent homeowners are taking the bait, convinced that their lives and neighborhoods would be better off without “their kind.”
That’s right, I’m talking about…renters.
To their credit, none of these anti-renter zealots are suggesting that renters be crucified, hung, or put in stocks, but I think it has more to do with the fact that such structures would violate architectural review committee rules.
The bigotry is manifesting itself in “rental restrictions” popping up in the CCR’s of homeowner associations all over the city.
Rental restrictions dictate that homeowners cannot rent out their homes to other people unless they are already doing so.
It also says that new buyers, particularly investors, cannot rent out their home.
In my not-so-humble opinion, I think it’s one of the most un-American rules I’ve heard of since Jim Crow died.
Although you think you own and control your home and property, a board can make a rule that tells you what you can and can’t do with it, and restricts who you can sell it to.
According to the myth which has been proffered in the propaganda pushing for the eradication of renters in our lifetime, the elimination of non-owners will increase your property value.
Apparently, renters are the bane of the residential world, leeches and parasites that drain a community of its escalating resale values and destroy its quality of life.
Of course, the “increasing property value” is the same excuse they use for punishing wayward residents who fail to get their garbage cans in on time, or who don’t get permission before planting rose bushes.
I suspect we’ll eventually see “increasing property value” as the reason why residents aren’t permitted outside their homes between 7 p.m. and dawn, why families will be limited to no more than 2.3 children, and why Subarus and cars built before 2003 will be banned from driving on local HOA streets.
According to several realtors, the rental restrictions are having the opposite effect, chilling property values because up to 40% (depending on which realtor you talk to) of the new home buyers are investors, or folks who intend to rent the property for two or three years until they are ready to retire.
I’m not the smartest person (I’m a renter, so how smart could I be?), but according to the most basic economic principle of supply and demand, if you have six potential buyers instead of 10, meaning less demand, your price must go down.
But I’m more disturbed by the discrimination against the mortgage-challenged.
Before long, I expect to see signs cropping up in stores saying “Non-Renters Only” and little posters above drinking fountains with “Renters” and “Non-Renters” separating the bad people from the good people.
I’m even more disturbed because some of the people voting for this evil codicil were once renters themselves.
They’re the ones who say “I don’t have anything against renters, I just wouldn’t want my daughter to marry one.”
To the homeowners in associations which haven’t yet adopted these measures, I implore you to have a heart, be an American, use some common sense, protect your property values, and vote against these idiotic anti-renter rules.
And to the association board members promoting rental restrictions, I would beg that you stop hating the poor, downtrodden renters, and go back to hating people who paint their fences tan instead of taupe.

8 Comments:

Blogger Terri said...

Enjoyed this one immensely after reeiving the same notification from our HOA! What's going on with our town? We bought as part time residents, and while we're not interested in renting out at this time, I'd hate to lose that option. Not sure what's sparked the sudden interest other than maybe an unemployed lawyer?

5:38 PM

 
Blogger michelle said...

That's what happens when the many don't speak up and let the few think for them....Here we come Communism...I know it's not that bad but when you think of what you have control of and what you don't, how far away could it be...Ponder that thought

9:14 PM

 
Blogger Workman Chronicles said...

Workman Chronicles said...
Terri, the interest is from the association boards, and particularly the property management companies which service them.

The management companies claim that most of their headaches come from renters. If they can eliminate renters, they believe they can eliminate their extra work.

I have a press release from the local board of realtors that addresses the fallacies in the rental restriction thinking that I'm posting on the website at www.mesquedia.com.

Michelle, it's even worse than Communism...it's a continuation of something that has been happening quietly in this country, a country which was founded by people who were tired of the system of "Haves" and "Have Nots" which was prevalent in Europe before the founding of America.

It is one more downpour eroding what's left of America's "middle class." Here in Mesquite, you have a huge contingent of wealthy retirees, and a huge contingent of Hispanic immigrants working for minimum wage. Not a whole lot in between, and us 'tweeners are getting smaller in number every day because there is no affordable housing. Now, with fewer rental properties to choose from, meaning rentals are going to get even more expensive, I'm afraid I won't be able to live here much longer.

And I hate that, because I really love this place.

*Morris

7:44 PM

 
Blogger michelle said...

We have laws in Canada that protect the owners and the renters. On many times over the last 17 years I have hated the renters around my "owned" home but I would never be so predjudice to want just "owners", as owners can be just as much of a pain in the ass.

10:53 AM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hey Morris. What I've never understood is, I grow up in a particular community, go to school, work part time jobs, drive "teenager" cars, and get in all the "right" trouble. That's all cool because I live in a house my dad is buying.

At an appropriate age, I get too big for my britches and decide to move out of the house my dad is buying and me and a few guys who just moved out of houses their folks are buying decide to rent a place.

Same people, from the same community, same respectable family names... but now something's different. We're "Renters". No longer welcome, no longer wanted...

I guess we would have been more respectable had we each chose to live in our parent's basements until our parents died and we inhereted the houses. Then the same people who look down on "renters" would defend our right to not have to pay an inheretance tax. ;~D

9:25 PM

 
Blogger Workman Chronicles said...

I agree with you on that, Cindra. In fact, there ARE rules in the HOAs designed to protect against bad behavior. In fact, they get pretty anal about some of the rules...can't leave a garden hose out (not even on one of those spindles designed to hold a hose), garbage can must be in by a certain time on garbage day, garbage can must be in back of house or in garage, not on the side, garage door must not be left open for more than a few minutes...BELIEVE me, they have enough rules to keep renters and everybody else in check.

I also understand that some renters can be annoying, Michelle. As you say, just like some owners can be annoying. The difference is that renters can be kicked out, while you just have to endure other obnoxious owners.

Unfortunately, ParaTed, I think you're on to something. It's as if there is something innate in the American psyche that insists on prejudice in some form. If it's not a prejudice against blacks, it's a prejudice against Hispanics. If not Hispanics, it's Jews. Now that it's politically incorrect to discriminate against ethnic groups, the burning American desire to be a bigot has extended to the newest underclass: renters.

I hate to quote anything from Rodney King (of L.A. police beating fame), but damn it...can't we all just get along?

*Morris

6:26 AM

 
Anonymous Anonymous said...

"can't leave a garden hose out (not even on one of those spindles designed to hold a hose), garbage can must be in by a certain time on garbage day, garbage can must be in back of house or in garage, not on the side, garage door must not be left open for more than a few minutes..."

Basically they are saying, "You can live here as long as you make it look like nobody lives here". ;~D

4:48 PM

 
Blogger Workman Chronicles said...

I never thought of it that way, but you're exactly right, ParaTed. Drive around most of these neighborhoods and it's like an upscale ghost town. No cars in the driveways, no actual signs of life.

Ken, in another slap in the face to democracy, renters are not permitted to run for the HOA board. They are also not allowed to vote, since they aren't property owners.

Didn't we go to war with an English king a couple of hundred years ago over "taxation without representation?" SOme people just have to learn the lesson over and over again.

It is so un-American.

*Morris

6:37 AM

 

Post a Comment

<< Home